chenry39 c
map-marker Forest Knolls, California

ANTIQUE TRADERS SAN FRANCISCO SELLS FAKE TIFFANY LAMPS

I WAS SOLD A FAKE TIFFANY LAMP BASE BY ALAN SCHNEIDER OF ANTIQUE TRADERS IN SAN FRANCICO CA. HE TOLD ME IT WAS A REAL TIFFANY BASE BUT IT TURNS OUT TO BE FAKE. THE SHADE THAT CAME WITH THE LAMP WAS NOT SIGNED AND COULD BE FAKE ALSO. I COMPLAINED TO THE BBB AND THEY SENT MR. SCHNEIDER SEVERAL LETTERS AND HE NEVER RESPONDED. WHAT KIND OF CUSTOMER SERVICE IS THIS? HE SAYS HE HAS BEEN IN BUSINESS 38 YEARS..I WONDER HOW MANY OTHER PEOPLE HE HAS DONE THIS KIND OF THING TO? I WOULD AVOID THIS PLACDE AND DEAL WITH ONLY REPUTABLE DEALERS.
View full review
Loss:
$140
17 comments
Guest

Good old Alan, Have not seen him in years, yep he had repo, and good Tiffany Studios items mixed all through his store, and that was 15 years ago. Folks it's buyers beware, and it's much worse today than it used to be, they all lie today, if you have been collecting for 50+ years and have researched for most of that you still can get smacked, you better know what the h you are doing, and better know Tiffany Glass like the back of your hand.

Today the biggest Dealers all over the country are Hogs and just in it for the bucks, they have no interest in collecting Tiffany Studios items. The Lamps are the Worst Ones, there are many fakes abound, and if it's good you will be told it's fake, so they steal it, if you ever want to sell.

Tiffany Has become a cut through game, so know what you are doing, today all Antiques are a scam, paintings are even much worse.??? BEWARE, BEWARE,BEWARE, also watch the auctions they are where the fakes are born, J.R.

Guest
reply icon Replying to comment of Guest-853997

you might want to come and see the store before making judgement ,the antique traders has been in business at the same location in san Francisco for the past 45 years.....we only sell authentic articles of the art nouveau period.,...please give us an opportunity and making your own conclusion...thanks, the owner

Guest

While customer's comment is years old, I am surprised to read this about Alan Schneider. I'm a collector of Tiffany Lamps & Vases and have purchased seven items from The Antique Traders over the last 20+ years and have found his product to not only be 100% authentic but Schneider to be extremely knowledgeable and honest. I'm pretty savvy when it comes to Art Nouveau pieces and while we live in Houston and thus, must travel to find pieces to enhance our collection, know that The Antique Traders and one NY store are the only two destinations I seek out to build our collection.

Guest
reply icon Replying to comment of Guest-846356

Check your stuff Sir????????????

Guest

You cant buy an original tiffany finial for 140.00 only a novice would buy the lamp. Its probably Dale Tiffany.

Do your home work A close friend sold a tiffany lamp last year for 1.65 million dollars. let the buyer beware If its too good to be true it is

Guest
reply icon Replying to comment of Guest-596697

B.S. THERE IS NO LAMP THAT RARE YOUR FULL OF IT, 50+ YEARS OF COLLECTING I WATCH SIR LOL.LOL.LOL.

Guest

This is absolutely true. I have backup from 3 major auction houses the window is a fake, the base is not correct and the shade is questionable.

I asked for a refund but he would not refund my money. The BBB tried to help but Mr. Alan Schneider would not respond to their letters.

He knew he was selling fake Tiffany. Only deal with reputable Dealers.

Guest
reply icon Replying to comment of Guest-568116

I have traveled to SF many times over the last 20 years and was introduced to Alan Schneider when I first visited his shop. I collect Tiffany and am very savvy about what is real and what is questionable and thus have to respond to chenry's experience.

Over the years I have purchased three Tiffany lamps, five Tiffany vases and one Tiffany chandelier, all exquisite and all most assuredly authentic. All from Alan Schneider who I have found to be among the most knowledgeable and certainly an incredibly honest Tiffany dealer.

He is the only person on the West Coast with a significant collection of Tiffany (the others in NY) and a great plus, he has offered to purchase back from me any of the items I bought from him (I wouldn't part with any of them).

Guest
reply icon Replying to comment of Guest-827578

Hello missy, try to sell it now?????????? you will only get 1/2 your investment back the tiffany market has all but crashed because of the N.Y.

AND N.J.

boys it's the lowest in 50 years. best of luck lady

Guest

THIS IS A FALSE STATEMENT AS I HAVE BEEN IN THIS BUSINESS AT THIS LOCATION FOR 43 YEARS AND HAVE HAD NO, NO OTHER COMPLAINTS..

View more comments (16)
chenry39 c
map-marker Forest Knolls, California

FAKE TIFFANY WINDOW SOLD BY ALAN SCHNIDER OWNER OF ANTIQUE TRADERS SAN FRANCISCO

I was duped into buying a fake Tiffany window by Alan Schneider owner of Antique Traders in San Francisco. I was just getting started collecting Tiffany and I trusted Alan Schneider who has 35 years experience in Tiffany and selling antiques. Watch out for this guy he is slick. Several experts from major auction houses examined the Tiffany and told me I paid 20 times what this fake is worth. I asked the store owner to cancel the sale and refund my money but he refuses. Antique Traders in San Francisco and the owner Alan Schneider is not to be trusted.
View full review
Loss:
$150
11 comments
Guest

No trust and sincerity according to this. Watch out, people.

Guest

I have had three experts that work for the major auction houses look at the window and each one of them told me it is a fake. The lamp base a questionable with non Tiffany parts on it and a shade not signed that may be also fake.

This guy is evil, a flim flam.

He took my money and does not stand behind what he sells. Only deal with reputable Dealers.

Guest

I HAVE BEEN IN THIS SAME LOCATION IN SAN FRANCISCO FOR 43 YEARS AND THIS IS THE ONLY COMPLAINT....IT IS FALSE...

chenry39 c

What does being a very rich human have to do with anything? Now he says it is a period window..I have written correspondence from him indicating it was by Tiffany.

I asked him to cancell the sale and refund my money and he would not. Only deal with reputable dealers.

Guest

this man is just a very rich human being that was told originally that I would buy the window back from him over a year ago...he would not talk about it, but wanted to make waves. I told him originally that I was not guarantee the window to be tiffany, but from the period , but he would not listen....he is the only person in 40 years that has complained about my business and my honesty..so If you want to hear the truth of the issue, please contact me at my business number or just come and talk with me...this is embarrassng , but I have no choice but to write this response.....

chenry39 c

I had two top Tiffany experts look at the window and two experts from major auction houses look at the window and ALL OF THEM told me it was not by Tiffany. This man really hurt me financially.

Guest

this is totally a false statement..I never sold him a window that was fake...I also offered to by it back when he questioned it after I had other experts look at it..also the lamp was supported by another expert to be correct..this guy never even contacted me regarding the lamp question...totally false as I have been in business for 40 and his complaint is the only one...

Guest

Maybe the BBB could be of help to you. With all due respect,I believe most of the original Tiffany stained glass either lamps or whatever it may be are in museums.

Guest

Wow..they should do what they did to the guys selling fake goods at fishermans warf and put him in jail.

Guest

:cry

View more comments (10)

Why Trust Reviews on PissedConsumer?

  • Professional auto and live moderation
  • 100% user-generated content
  • Equal opportunity and protection
  • Zero tolerance for fake reviews
  • Verified content
  • PissedConsumer is on the Inc. 5000 list

For more information read Blog article